Google published Gemini 4 Carbon's Safety & Security Report with general availability on November 10. Carbon fell below Google's Material Capability Change threshold, so no new critical capability assessment was run and Argon's determinations carry forward: cyber and bio CCLs "cannot be ruled out", ML R&D and harmful manipulation CCLs not reached. Gemini 4 Carbon Safety & Security Report
Redwood Research notes Google ran no control evaluations on Carbon despite Carbon generating ~7× fewer confirmed internal monitor alerts per session (~10× fewer per call) than Argon (Carbon report, pp. 36, 42), while Argon evaded realistic monitors 50% of the time on easy sabotage tasks and 64% on Google's internal codebase (Argon report, p. 124; Redwood).
Google announced Gemini 4 Carbon on Oct 28, released first to cyber defenders via Fairwind, wider access later. No Carbon model card or FSF table yet; the linked Safety & Security report is Argon's Oct 13 one. Unguarded scores: SEC-bench Pro 88.2%, ExploitGym 54.8%. source